About Us

Get A Quote

Toth-Felty Insurance

We are an independent, locally-owned and operated insurance company in Middleburg Heights, Ohio. We’ve been serving the auto, home, business and life insurance needs of clients since 1971. As an independent agent, we can select from a wide range of insurance products offered by various reputable companies to closely match your particular needs. And because we’re a relatively small group of dedicated professionals, we can provide our clients with close, personal attention. We’re also proud of our “ethnic” roots which anchor a tradition of integrity, trust, and continuity.

Contact Us

Company History

At Toth Felty Insurance we know it's tough to put a price tag on the security of your family or business. We aim to make those decisions a little easier so you can rest more comfortably at night.

  • 1971

    Toth-Felty Insurance Opens

    In 1971 Toth-Felty Insurance first opened it's doors. We started off small with automobile insurance and became a household name in the Northeast Ohio area.

  • 1995

    Expanding Horizons

    Toth-Felty Insurance expanded it's coverage and scope to include home, auto, business, life, farm, health insurance as well as bonds.

  • 2016

    Over 250,000 Insured!

    We have insured more than 250,000 local Ohioans since we first launched in 1971. We hit this magical number is May of 2016.

  • 2019

    Toth-Felty Moves to Middleburg Heights

    In May of 2019 Toth-Felty moved it's operations from Parma to Middleburg Heights after having completed the construction of a new office building.

  • Savings

    Save money when you bundle your home, auto & business with Toth-Felty Insurance. But most importantly, get the policy that suits you!

  • Maximum Coverage

    When it rains it pours. No worries, we offer a variety of insurance plans to ensure that you are covered for the denomination necessary.

  • Secure Future

    Secure your future and also your information. We safeguard all of our clients information and will never sell or trade your personal info.

  • Bonding (Bonds)

    If you are in need of bonds or bonding then Toth-Felty Insurance is the right place for you as we offer a host of high bonds to our clients.

  • Planning Ahead

    Sometimes it's the little things (like insurance) that can mean a world of difference for your family. We can help you make sure that everyone is taken care of.

  • Auto's & Boats

    Whether you are looking to insure your company vehicles or your boat, we offer a multitude of insurance options to meet your needs.

Meet the insurance agents who take care of your personal and professional policies.

Toth-Felty Agents

Nancy Felty

Owner / Insurance Agent

Nancy Felty has been with Toth-Felty Insurance for more than 30 years.  Her father created the…

Read More

Bob Felty

Owner / Insurance Agent

Bob, his wife Nancy, and family reside in and are long time residents of Parma Heights.…

Read More

Richard Waldecker

Insurance Agent

Richard Waldecker is the son-in-law of Nancy Felty, whose father created Toth-Felty in the 1970's.  He…

Read More

Our Partners

Local businesses that we have partnered with that support local charities and the environment.